The day before Valentine’s Day (after our 4th date) he asked me if I had a boyfriend.

— JB

Aftermath: I should have asked if he had a girlfriend.

I went to the bathroom to change into something “a little more comfortable” and when I came out he was snoring.

— Hayley

Aftermath: I grabbed my things and left.

He started paying for his baby mama’s cell phone. Sexy pics started going back and forth.

— JO

Aftermath: I called it quits. Two years later he finally admitted he cheated.

He gave me a calendar of himself for Christmas.

— Britney

Aftermath: Including snapshots of him on the toilet.

He cheated on me with his old babysitter.

— Lisa

Aftermath: Ewww.