Bounty Hunter Contest!


ItWasOverWhen.com teamed up with Sony Pictures in anticipation of the Jennifer Aniston / Gerard Butler romantic comedy “The Bounty Hunter.” In short, we’ve collected your favorite stories of romantic dead ends and in exchange for free stuff.

The contest is now closed, but come back to read our winning entries over the next two weeks!

 

New stories added daily!

 

“New in Town”

best of weird

We moved to a new city together and as soon as I started making new friends. He didn’t and he became very suspicious. In fact, one night he asked my co-workers if I was “really at work,” followed me home from work and inspected my underwear when I was taking a shower. It promptly ended that night.

—Nicole

Aftermath: I had to live with his crazy behavior for the next three months afterward until I could move into a new place.

Bookmark and Share

This post was submitted by Nicole.

6
Share your story

“Elton John”

best of clashes

During a phone conversation, I mentioned I was going to see Elton John with my siblings. He made an anti-gay remark which I, at first, thought was a joke. He then proceeded to get angry and go on an anti-gay rant. When I told him that I had several gay friends and was pro-gay rights and that I tried to explain things to my young daughter so she would be tolerant, he told me he thought less of me as a person and said maybe I should start taking my daughter to church.

—MH

Aftermath: I hung up on him. He proceeded to call me or have his friend call me for days. I didn’t answer. I’m now happily married—to someone else.

Bookmark and Share

This post was submitted by MH.

42
Share your story

“Pre-Used”

best of sex

He suggested we have sex and I agreed if he had protection. He stands up, digs through his laundry hamper and pulls out a condom that’s already been opened and unrolled. He seriously didn’t think anything was wrong with using a pre-used condom.

—Allison

Aftermath: I never slept with him, though we continued seeing each other for a month because I felt bad. He was a nice guy, just totally clueless. He cried when I broke up with him and threw his cell phone into the street.

Bookmark and Share

This post was submitted by Allison.

29
Share your story

“The Others”

best of weird

We were cuddling on his couch watching The Others and he said…“I could keep you here forever!” It was our first date…

—Kaye

Aftermath: He called me the next Saturday over a dozen times and I ignored him. He finally gave up.

Bookmark and Share
2
Share your story

“Ask the Cat”

best of chemistry

It was over when he asked his cats what I wanted to do that day. In a doggy voice.

—Mizz Gooch

Aftermath: I f***ing hate cats. Only later did I find out that he named one of his cats after his favorite porn star.

Bookmark and Share

This post was submitted by Mizz Gooch.

7
Share your story
 

You need to log in to vote

The blog owner requires users to be logged in to be able to vote for this post.

Alternatively, if you do not have an account yet you can create one here.

Powered by Vote It Up