During sex, she got really hot telling me fantasy stories about me having sex with a hot girl lifeguard after everyone had left the pool. She started worked out 2 nights a week with friends. Shortly thereafter I found out that the “workout friends” was a gym teacher. At his school. At the pool. After everyone else had left.

—SwimFan

Aftermath: She vehemently denied any wrongdoing; said that it was a coincidence, even after I received a cell phone video of proof. I filed for divorce.

This post was submitted by SwimFan.

3

One fateful night, missionary style, the condom broke within a few pumps. I reared back to put on a new one, and it hit me. The most awful smell my nose had ever experienced. This was new, and I uncontrollably went limp. She asked what happened, and too nice to say it, I told her I had an E.D. type of disorder

—Bukowski

Aftermath: I went and got an STD check, fearing she had a rare dead animal disease. I was clean, we never had sex again, and she told friends I go limp easily. Nice guys finish last!

This post was submitted by Bukowski.

5

After we  had dated for 6 months, she told me that two nights earlier she had tried anal (which she told me was never gonna happen, lol).

—Ind

Aftermath: I got in my car and left.

This post was submitted by ind.

5

I knew it was over when I knocked on the bathroom door and he said “come in” only for me to see him taking a number 2 and eating breakfast simultaneously.

—Randi

Aftermath: It ended right there.

This post was submitted by Randi.

8

We were dating for about two months, and then he decided to tell me his ex-girlfriend was pregnant and it “might” be his child…one week before it was due.

—Lindsey

Aftermath: He left to go get a paternity test and be there for the birth. I haven’t talked to him since he left.

This post was submitted by Lindsey.

3