“Danglers”
We were having a great physical relationship when he asked me if I wanted to lick on his danglers while another guy rammed him in his backside (NOT the words he used!).
—EssCee
Aftermath: HIV test.
This post was submitted by EssCee.
46
Bounty Hunter Contest!
ItWasOverWhen.com teamed up with Sony Pictures in anticipation of the Jennifer Aniston / Gerard Butler romantic comedy “The Bounty Hunter.” In short, we’ve collected your favorite stories of romantic dead ends and in exchange for free stuff.
The contest is now closed, but come back to read our winning entries over the next two weeks!
New stories added daily!
“Next”
I had just arrived to pick her up for our first date when her little boy ran over to me and said, “My mom says you are going to be my next dad.” Yes, he said, “Next.” We went out that night and never again.
—Dace
Aftermath: I ran into her a year or so later and found out she had gotten married but was getting a divorce, after only a year. Her kid’s new daddy number 4.
This post was submitted by Dace.
6
“Rollercoaster”
We were each other’s first loves. Completely inseparable, we got together when I was 15, and stayed together for 3.3 years, even surviving several months of being in separate cities when I moved away for university. However, he stopped making effort, considered an hour to be “long distance” and he never listened anymore. So I ended it.
—Hannah
Aftermath: He is now with one of my best friends, and I don’t speak to either of them anymore. However, before they got together, I totally upgraded, and what I thought would be merely a fling has blossomed into an amazing relationship that is ironically what I would call real long distance—I am English and my boyfriend is Canadian. We met at university while he was here for the year and I couldn’t be happier with him. He is perfect for me and far exceeds my ex in EVERY way.
This post was submitted by Hannah.
7
“Creeper”
This girl took pictures of me from I don’t even know where, and spelled out her name and phone number out with them and put it on the roof of my car.
—JJ
Aftermath: I did call her, only to tell her that I would call the cops if it ever happened again. Something tells me that the girl is still single
This post was submitted by JJ.
50
“Friends with Benefits”
Slept with this guy a few times. But we didn’t want tell anybody. We told everyone, “We’re friends.” But the word got out. We got caught coming out of a hotel, so while I admitted the truth, he said nothing happened. We stayed as friends. But I stopped sleeping with him.
—Justanothergirl
Aftermath: Every time we hang out, he sees me making out with my guy. The trace of jealousy on his face couldn’t be rubbed off. I make a joke out of it: “We’ll be having great sex tonight. You know what that’s like…”
This post was submitted by Justanothergirl.
3
