He told me the song “Dirty Little Secret” reminded him of me. Then, my roommate met his fiance…

— SassyPant

Aftermath: We told her everything.

At my birthday party he started buying everyone drinks. At the end of the night, he asked if I would pay for the tab. 

— Amanda

Aftermath: We broke up via police escort the following year.

Saw my girlfriend at the jewelry store looking at rings. Found out she was picking out an engagement ring with her soon-to-be fiance.

— DC

Aftermath: They had a baby and broke up.

She invited me to go to Boston. Somehow we ended up in the diamond district, “to pick something out for her mom.” Before I knew it we were sitting in a little office being shown diamonds for engagement rings. I had been tricked.

— Mark

Aftermath: I left angry. Now I’m engaged to someone else.

My boyfriend of six years professed his love to me and asked me to move in with him, saying that he knew he wanted to be with me forever but he didn’t think he could marry me.

— Confused and alone

Aftermath: We broke up that night.